, ,

Environmental Groups Wary Of Shipping Tar Sands Oil On Great Lakes

By
The docks and inner harbor at Superior, Wisconsin.
The docks and inner harbor at Superior, Wisconsin. Photo: Pete Zarria (CC-BY-NC)

A coalition of environmental groups doesn’t want any Great Lakes communities to allow oil to be shipped on their waterways. This comes as a Superior refinery asks Wisconsin for a permit to ship oil on Lake Superior.

Calumet Refinery says shipping Alberta tar sands oil on barges from a dock in Superior would be safe and efficient, and would solve the problem of not having enough pipeline capacity from the booming Canadian oil fields. It wants a permit to spend $20 million on an oil terminal in Superior.

Minnesota Environmental Partnership Program Coordinator Andrew Slade says a spill on Lake Superior, the deepest of the Great Lakes, would take decades to clean up. He says heavy crude from the tar sands must not be allowed on the lakes.

Stay informed on the latest news

Sign up for WPR’s email newsletter.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

“Think about this avalanche or flood or volcano of tar sands,” Slade said, “trying to get out of that Edmonton area, trying to get to the Atlantic Ocean, the Pacific Ocean…

“There is no way to just say no to this in any one place or another. It really has to be the work of an informed, watchful citizenry and strong legislation,” he continued.

In the same teleconference with reporters, however, Coast Guard Incident Manager Jerry Popiel of Cleveland says he hasn’t seen a proposal from Calumet, but it would have to include oil spill recovery plans.

“We’re committed that any company that’s going to try to do this, they’re going to have to demonstrate to us that they can recover submerged oil by all the categories that are required by the law,” Popiel said.

A Calumet spokesman wouldn’t give a telephone interview on this, but did send a statement to say the company is working to find refineries in the mid-continent and eastern United States to take tar sands oil shipments.