Conservative group sues Wisconsin secretary of state over open records related to her appointment

A conservative policy group filed an open records lawsuit on Tuesday against Wisconsin Secretary of State Sarah Godlewski, accusing her of blocking a request it hopes can shed light on the events that led to her appointment earlier this year.

Democratic Gov. Tony Evers tapped Godlewski for the role on March 17, the day her predecessor, longtime Secretary of State Doug La Follette, abruptly resigned less than three months into his eleventh consecutive term. Republicans who control the state Legislature blasted the move as a quid pro quo and called on Evers to instead hold a special election to fill the job.

Godlewski, who previously served as state treasurer, was coming off an unsuccessful 2022 midterm bid for U.S. Senate. She and two other top contenders dropped out of the crowded Democratic primary in the same week in July to clear the way for former Lt. Gov. Mandela Barnes, who ultimately lost to incumbent Republican Sen. Ron Johnson.

Godlewski has repeatedly denied allegations that Evers handed her the office as a reward for dropping out of the Senate race and endorsing Barnes. She told The Associated Press in her first interview after being appointed that the governor’s decision came as a complete surprise to her.

The Institute for Reforming Government, a conservative, Wisconsin-based policy group, filed an open records request with Godlewski’s office on the same day she was appointed. The request asked for copies of all correspondence La Follette had sent to Evers, Godlewski and deputy secretaries of state in the year before he resigned.

Godlewski’s office confirmed on May 25, after the IRG sent multiple emails asking for updates, that it had received the request, according to a complaint filed in Waukesha County Court on Tuesday and provided to the AP in advance. The complaint alleges that since May 25, Godlewski’s office has not turned over any records, denied the request, or sent an update — effectively blocking the request.

Godlewski did not immediately return a voicemail left Tuesday morning.

Republicans have gutted the secretary of state’s office over the past 10 years, stripping the role of most of its power and staff before relegating La Follette to a small office in the Capitol basement. The most significant duty the office still holds is sitting on the state timber board.

In his resignation letter, La Follette said he was leaving because he was tired of working with such limited resources.

During the midterm, Republicans had been openly discussing transferring election administration duties from a bipartisan commission to the secretary of state’s office, following the lead of at least 38 other states. The GOP candidate for the office last year, former Republican state Rep. Amy Loudenbeck, narrowly lost to La Follette by about 7,500 votes.