, ,

Democrats flip key Wisconsin Senate seats

The wins by Democrats could give them a chance to flip the state Senate in 2026

By
A wide view of the Senate chambers showing the seats and rotunda ceiling.
The Wisconsin State Senate chambers on Thursday, Dec. 14, 2023, at the Wisconsin State Capitol in Madison, Wis. Angela Major/WPR

Democrats have chipped away at the massive GOP majority in the Wisconsin Senate, flipping four Republican districts with the help of the state’s new competitive political maps. 

The maps were drawn by Democratic Gov. Tony Evers and passed by Republican lawmakers earlier this year under pressure from the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s new liberal majority. Unlike the Republican-drawn maps that preceded them, the new district lines gave either party a realistic shot at winning the Legislature.

In the Assembly, where all 99 districts are up for election every two years, that gave either party a chance to win control of the chamber. This year, it was Republicans who won a majority.

Stay informed on the latest news

Sign up for WPR’s email newsletter.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

In the Senate, where half the chamber is up for election every two years, Democrats had no realistic shot at winning the chamber this year. Republicans went into the election with a 22-10 supermajority, with one Democratic seat open.

With four GOP seats flipped, that leaves an 18-15 seat Republican majority, meaning Democrats could take the Senate in 2026 if they flip two more districts.

Here’s how it played out.

14th Senate District: Democrat Sarah Keyeski defeats Republican Joan Ballweg

Democrat Sarah Keyeski, left, and Republican incumbent Joan Ballweg, right.
Democrat Sarah Keyeski, left, and Republican incumbent Joan Ballweg, right, are competing for a seat in the Wisconsin state Senate representing the 14th District. Photos courtesy of the campaigns

In the 14th Senate District, Democrat Sarah Keyeski of Lodi defeated Republican Sen. Joan Ballweg by about a 2 percent margin, according to preliminary numbers by the Associated Press. Ballweg is a longtime lawmaker from Markesan. Keyeski is a mental health counselor with no previous political experience. 

While Ballweg was the incumbent, the new district bore little resemblance to the one she held under the old map, running east and west instead of north and south. The new seat includes all of Richland and Sauk counties and portions of several others, including Dane County, a Democratic stronghold.

30th Senate District: Democrat Jamie Wall defeats Republican Jim Rafter

Democrat Jamie Wall, left, and Republican Jim Rafter, right.
Democrat Jamie Wall, left, and Republican Jim Rafter, right, are competing for a seat in the Wisconsin state Senate representing the 30th District. Photos courtesy of the campaigns

In Green Bay’s 30th Senate District, an open seat, Democrat Jamie Wall defeated Republican Jim Rafter by about a 5 percent margin, according to the AP. Wall is a business consultant who ran unsuccessfully for the U.S. House in 2012. Rafter spent a career working in the tech sector, and has been on the Allouez Village Board for the past decade, spending the last eight years as president.

The new 30th Senate District includes much of the city of Green Bay, along with neighboring De Pere, Ashwaubenon, Allouez and Bellevue. It was previously held by Republican Sen. Eric Wimberger, who ran for the neighboring 2nd Senate District, a strongly Republican seat.

8th Senate District: Democrat Jodi Habush Sinykin leads Republican Duey Stroebel

Democrat Jodi Habush Sinykin, left, and Republican incumbent Duey Stroebel, right.
Democrat Jodi Habush Sinykin, left, and Republican incumbent Duey Stroebel, right, are competing for a seat in the Wisconsin state Senate representing the 8th District. Photos courtesy of the campaigns

In southeast Wisconsin’s 8th Senate District, Democrat Jodi Habush Sinykin narrowly defeated Republican Sen. Duey Stroebel according to a race call by The Associated Press shortly before 6:00 p.m. Wednesday.

Sinykin, an attorney who specializes in environmental law, is a partner at the Milwaukee-based Habush Habush and Rottier. Stroebel has served for 14 years in the Legislature, including nine in the Senate, but the district was about 80 percent new to him.

Sinykin will fill the seat currently held by Republican Sen. Dan Knodl, who decided to run for a state Assembly seat instead.

The 8th Senate District was part of the critical battle for the suburbs, a region once dominated by Republicans where Democrats have made inroads.

18th Senate District: Democrat Kristin Alfheim leads Republican Anthony Wayne Phillips

In the 18th Senate District, Democrat Kristin Alfheim defeated Republican Anthony Wayne Phillips by a nearly 7 percentage point margin. Both Alfheim and Wayne Phillips are from Appleton.

The new map gave Democrats a sizable advantage in the 18th, which is currently held by Republican Sen. Dan Feyen. After redistricting, Feyen ran in the 20th Senate District, the most Republican-leaning seat up for election this year.

Both parties hold other seats

Other state Senate races went largely as expected. 

In one left-leaning district, the 32nd, Democratic Sen. Brad Pfaff of Onalaska fended off Republican challenger Stacey Klein of Trempealeau.

In all other seats currently held by Democrats, there were no Republican challengers. And in six right-leaning districts currently held by Republicans, the GOP candidates won handily.

View results for all 16 Senate districts on the ballot this year.

Editor’s note: This story was updated Wednesday evening to reflect the latest race calls by the Associated Press.